Welcome! We regret to inform you that the Injury Board National News Desk has been discontinued. Feel free to browse around and enjoy our previously published articles, or visit The Injury Blog Network for the latest in personal injury news.

Save Money – Deport The Patient

Posted by Jane Akre
Friday, July 24, 2009 2:06 PM EST
Category: Major Medical, In The Workplace
Tags: Medicare, Luis Jimenez, Deporting, Health Care Reform, Immigrant Healthcare

Should a hospital deport a man who needs a lifetime of care? That is the decision in front of a jury in Florida. 

Jury Will Decide If Unreasonable and Unwarrented



IMAGE SOURCE:  So Florida Sun Sentinel Web site/ image of Luis Jimenez


A South Florida hospital quietly chartered a plane and sent a brain-injured Guatemalan man back to his country over the objections of his family and guardian.  Now a case against the hospital is in the hands of the jury. 

Closing arguments concluded Thursday in a first-of-its kind case that pits health care against immigration and tests whether hospitals should provide long-term care for patients who don’t qualify for state and federal aid. 

37-year-old Luis Jimenez, a Mayan Indian, was an illegal immigrant, working in Florida and sending money back home to his wife and young sons when in 2000, a drunk driver hit the van in which he was riding.  Jimenez was left a paraplegic with severe brain injury and disabilities.  His cousin, Montejo Gaspar became his legal guardian, reports the South Florida Sun Sentinel.

Over three years,  Martin Memorial Medical Center in Stuart, Florida provided $1.5 million worth of care. 

But the hospital sought a letter from the Guatemalan government and got a Florida judge to order a transfer of the patient.  In July 2003, it quietly chartered a $30,000 charter plane and flew Jimenez back to Guatemala, without telling the family.  His cousin, Gaspar filed an emergency request to stop the transfer. 


Federal law states the hospital was required to care for Jimenez. Hospitals that receive Medicare reimbursements are required to provide emergency care until a patient is stabilized and a discharge plan is filed.

The problem was that no institution would care for Jimenez because of his immigration status.  

His cousin filed the lawsuit seeking nearly $1 million to cover Jimenez’s lifetime care costs in Guatemala. Also included are punitive damages to discourage other hospitals for deporting patients, a job usually left up to federal immigration authorities.

A 2004 appeals court decision established the hospital overstepped its authority by sending Jimenez back to Guatemala and that he was “unlawfully detained and deprived of liberty”.

But in his closing arguments of the month-long trial, hospital attorney, Scott Machaud asked the six-member jury why Martin Memorial should pay for a lifetime of care “for injuries we didn’t even cause?”

A lawyer for Gaspar and Jimenez said the hospital decided to secretly send Jimenez back to Guatemala to halt what would have been a long and expensive appeals process.

"The plan was designed once and for all to stop the meter from running, to stop the expenses ... to stop the case from going all the way up to the Supreme Court — because Luis Jimenez was gone," attorney Jack Hill told the packed courtroom in Stuart, just north of the exclusive community of Palm Beach.

The jury is charged with finding whether the hospital's actions were "unreasonable and unwarranted under the circumstances," reports the New York Times, and whether the actions had harmed Jimenez.

An Internist POV

Writing in the San Francisco Chronicle, Doc Gurley says most Americans feel they would also be dumped after three years, but "being discharged here in the States is not quite the same as being discharged to a remote Guatemalan mountain village, particularly for someone with serious permanent illness."  A priest visint Jimenez said he appeared clean, living with his mother in a one room home, "and would survive, I guessed, until his first pneumonia".

Doc Gurley says "If you discharge someone without meeting those standards (stabilized patient and a discharge plan) tht's what's called, in this country's jargon, dumping - a practice that's generally considered not only unethical, but one that can also get a hospital's license yanked."

Set Precedent

The case could set precedent in Florida and possibly beyond. A spokeswoman from the South Florida Hospital & Healthcare Association says this case may make hospital more reluctant to admit uninsured immigrants.

The priest from South Florida who visited Jimenez, Rev. Frank O’Laughlin said a country that uses cheap labor from other countries should factor in the cost of catastrophic injuries, either coverage coming from employers or ensuring hospital care in case of an accident.

Among the roughly 47 million uninsured in the U.S. an estimated 15 percent are illegal immigrants, according to the Pew Hispanic Center.   #


Posted by James Cool
Friday, July 24, 2009 3:58 PM EST

This is a horribly difficult question. What do you do? You cannot afford to care for everyone, particularly those who are non-citizens. However, he's still a human being and his life has no less value than another's. What a terribly dilemma.

Anonymous User
Posted by jerry chapman
Friday, July 24, 2009 5:21 PM EST

protect our american citizens first. we aren't the HMO for the world. i hope this hospital wins the case. this is but one of thousands of cases that are closing hospitals nationwide. why should we be the caregiver for law breakers here illegally. hooray. finally someone is standing up for americans.

Anonymous User
Posted by Joan Petty
Sunday, July 26, 2009 5:22 AM EST

What happened to the Drunk Driver who caused the injury? Would it have mattered if the person was legal or illegal imgrant he was still injured? What happened to the Good Samaritian Act? No human being should be denied care. Our hospitals and many doctors receive Grants from our United States Government, Tax dollars that are set aside seperately and given to the healthcare facilities. Our country was formed on immigration from many countries. There would not be an American if it were not for our immigrent ancestors. I agree that America should stand up for Americans but do it with care. really good article Jane.

Posted by Jane Akre
Monday, July 27, 2009 12:14 PM EST


Isn't America better than that? Just a thought.

Comments for this article are closed.

About the National News Desk

Our mission is to seek the complete truth and provide a full and fair account of the events and issues that surround personal safety, accident prevention, and injury recovery.  We are committed to serving the public with honesty and integrity in these efforts.

Hurt in an accident? Contact an Injury Board member

Subscribe to Blog Updates

Enter your email address if you would like to receive email notifications when comments are made on this post.

Email address


RSS Feed

Add the National News Desk to your favorite RSS reader

Add to Google Reader Add to myYahoo Add to myMSN Add to Bloglines Add to Newsgator Add to Netvibes Add to Pageflakes